Italy’s data protection regulator, the Garante, announced a fine of €805 million (about $886 million) against Meta on Saturday. The regulator found that Facebook accessed users’ photos and videos without specific consent or adequate notice. The fine is one of the largest the Garante has ever issued.
What the investigation found
The case centers on Facebook’s “camera roll” suggestions feature, launched in 2023. According to the regulator, the feature browsed Android users’ photo galleries to recommend posts that could be enhanced with personal photos and videos. The Garante said related metadata was also accessed.
- Meta requested camera roll access through a single permission that covered multiple features with different requirements.
- The permission was preceded by a “non-specific notice” tied to other features, so users were not clearly told they were consenting to camera roll suggestions.
- The feature was reportedly enabled by default.
The regulator noted that a full grant of this permission can allow an app to access the entire device photo library, usually on a persistent basis, without users or regulators being able to verify what data is actually used. Italian data protection rules treat the smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere, so any access to stored information requires free and informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted or harm occurs.
Why the fine is so large
The Garante cited three factors: about 20 million Italian Android users were affected, the violation ran over a long period, and Meta did not cooperate fully during the probe. Meta had argued the regulator lacked jurisdiction, a claim the Garante rejected.
Required changes and Meta’s response
In addition to the fine, the Garante has ordered Meta to make changes within 60 days. These include obtaining consent through a request that is separate and specific to the feature, clearly explaining how the data will be used, and disabling the option by default. A Meta spokesperson said the company strongly disagrees with the decision, plans to appeal, and considers the fine disproportionate.
Takeaway for security and privacy teams
For organizations, the case underscores how broad Android permissions can expose entire device photo libraries, and how regulators may treat bundled consent as insufficient. Teams reviewing mobile app permissions should check whether apps request full media access and whether features that depend on it are opt-in.
